So often we come across “music aficionados” (I’ll refer to them as MA through this article) who always know anything and everything about music. Absolutely nothing wrong with that. In fact, these conversations are quite intriguing and enlightening. I had one such conversation with a MA.
Dinner was done, people were sitting and enjoying dessert and our MA was charged up. He starts off quoting some great singers, giving details of their songs, the music, the ragas used, lot of trivia about the song, singer and music director, etc. Folks were mesmerized by the abundance of information that this MA’s head could hold and recall at the press of a button. There was an occasional input from someone or the other, but mostly the response was just of tacit approval and appreciation.
I barely had any response because the MA was talking only about Hindi and Marathi music. Yes, I listen to a lot of Hindi music and occasionally some Marathi stuff too, and I know who Lata Mangeshkar or Kishore Kumar is, but that’s about it. MA was Buddha delivering his sermons under the Bodhi tree while I was a starry-eyed disciple.
Things were going good until MA decided to enter the touchy territory of Pop and Rock music. At this point, MA started to take liberties in defining music itself. It was time for starry-eyed, long-haired, black-tee-clad disciple (i.e. me) to shine and teach the master some lessons. Here is what followed…
MA: …and this pop and rock is crap. It can’t be called music. That Jackson fellow just keeps shouting “oww” and grabs his crotch as if he has ants in his pants. And those rock guys make so much noise and just scream out loud.
me: Jackson is a multi-platinum artist! And what you call noise is distortion. It’s an effect to go with the intensity of the song.
MA: Why do you need intensity in music? Listen to how melodious Lata sounds even at this age. (He always refers to these great singers by their first names as if he was their langotiya yaar (underwear friend i.e. childhood friend))
me: She sounds like Aerosmith’s Steven Tyler in Veer Zaara! (Ha ha! Got you there didn’t I buster? Do you call a rocker bad now or good? Coz you are definitely not going call Lata bad! me:1 MA:0)
MA: (neglecting my previous statement) They just jump and run around on the stage screaming and making noise.
me: You expect a rock band to sit cross-legged and perform? How do you think “Ajeeb Dastan Hai Yeh” would sound if Lata didi jumped around the stage? Wouldn’t look good right? So you have to give a performance that matches the genre of music.
MA: Are you trying to say Lata is not good?
me: Hell no! I respect her and she is hands down an amazing singer. But that doesn’t mean that other singers are not good.
MA: Rock and pop stars are not singers…it is not music!
me: What IS music?
MA: ummmm….errrr….songs that have melodies and rhythm.
me: The black metal band Children of Bodom uses keyboard melodies and rhythm! (me:2 MA:0)
MA: (after a long pause) I mean…uhhh…well…they don’t use ragas and don’t have control over their voices like Lata, Asha, Kishore, Rafi…
me: You are kidding me right?? Heard about chords, keys, modes?
MA: (oozing sarcasm) Right! Rock bands use notes and stuff to create noise.
me: Man! Do you even know how hard it is to actually co-ordinate the lead, rhythm and bass guitars with the drums? It f——-riggin (checking myself as parents are around) takes years of practice!
MA: But…
(I am in high gear and cut him off and continue)
me: Do you know how much stamina it takes to play a 2-3 hour show shredding your guitar, plucking those bass strings and pounding the drums at speeds reaching 200+ bpm (beats per min) at times? Do you know how difficult it is for the singer to keep jumping around and still having enough breath to sing in tune? I’m sure Lata didi can’t do that and most importantly, I wouldn’t want her doing that either. She is a great singer…possibly the greatest, but she is not a rockstar. Period! That doesn’t mean she is not good. She is good at what she does and rockstars are good at what they do. You definitely wouldn’t want to hear Alanis Morissette singing “Didi Tera Dewar Deewana”, do you??
MA: …ummmm….
(Cut!!)
me: Learn to appreciate all forms of music. You love the Hindi oldies…more power to you. But that doesn’t give you any liberty to criticize other music forms and musicians. I played drums and bass in a rock band and I know how many hours of practice I put in to go and give my best on stage. You won’t find me sitting and listening to Hindi songs, but you won’t find me criticizing them either. Because I love music! And to truly love, appreciate and enjoy music, you need to open up your mind and free it from your biases. It’s only then that you can truly call yourself a music aficionado. I’m done!
An eerie silence was followed by an approving nod from MA and smiles and murmurs from the other folks present out there. I winked at my brother as the topic shifted to cricket and I took a backseat.
ROCK ON!!!